Sell & Trade Your Cards

We’re always looking to purchase single cards, unopened vintage packs, and complete collections, as well as work out trades with fellow collectors. Whether you have a single graded grail, a binder passed down through your family, or a set you are looking to trade up from, we offer fair market cash payouts and straightforward trade options.

What We Buy & Trade For

We evaluate single cards, partial sets, and full collections across vintage sports, graded slabs, and select modern staples:

  • Vintage Sports Cards: Primary focus on 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s baseball, basketball, and football (Hall of Famers, key rookie cards, star commons, high-grade raw, or vintage slabs).
  • Graded Slabs: Graded cards across vintage and classic modern eras.
  • Modern Star Staples: Key rookie cards and iconic inserts of modern legends (e.g., Michael Jordan, Ken Griffey Jr., and breakout stars).
  • Complete & Estate Collections: Entire multi-sport accumulations, shoebox collections, binder collections, or lifetime estate sets.

How Outright Purchases Work

Selling your collection to us is straightforward and transparent:

  1. Send Us Details & Photos: Email photos of your cards or collection to mike@troha.com along with a brief overview of what you have.
  2. Market Evaluation: We review your items using recent completed sales data to establish a fair market valuation.
  3. Receive an Offer: We will reply with a competitive cash offer within 24–48 hours.
  4. Ship or Meet: Package your cards securely and send them via tracked shipping. Once received and verified, cash payouts are issued immediately via PayPal Goods & Services, Venmo, Zelle or Company Check.

How Trades Work

We love trading with the collecting community! If you see something in our inventory that you’d like to trade for:

  1. Submit Your Trade Proposal: Email mike@troha.com with photos of the card(s) you are offering and name the specific item listed on our site that you want in return.
  2. Mutual Valuation: We establish the fair market value for both your submission and our item using current market comps.
  3. Complete the Exchange: If trade values match up (or after adjusting for any cash added to balance the deal), both parties ship their items with tracking. Your new card is shipped out as soon as your trade package is received and inspected.

Tips for Submitting Your Collection

  • Take Clear Photos: Place raw cards on a flat, well-lit surface. For large binder collections, clear photos of full binder pages are great for an initial review.
  • Highlight Key Cards: Let us know upfront about any major Hall of Famers, rookie cards, or high-value key cards in the group.
  • Specify Cash vs. Trade: Let us know in your email whether you are seeking an immediate cash payout or looking for trade credit toward our current inventory.

Ready to get started? Email your photos and collection details to mike@troha.com and we will get back to you promptly!